श्रेयो हि ज्ञानमभ्यासाज्ज्ञानाद् ध्यानं विशिष्यतेध्यानात् कर्मफलत्यागस्त्यागाच्छान्तिरनन्तरम्
In plain words
Jñāna is indeed better than practice; Dhyāna is superior to jñāna; karma-phala-tyāga is greater than dhyāna, for peace follows immediately from tyāga.
Word for word
Better indeed [is] jñāna than practice; dhyāna excels jñāna; than dhyāna, the renunciation of the fruit of action; from renunciation, peace immediately.
श्रेयो हि ज्ञानमभ्यासाज्ज्ञानाद् ध्यानं विशिष्यतेध्यानात् कर्मफलत्यागस्त्यागाच्छान्तिरनन्तरम्
Other commentaries
The commentators
▸Bhagavadgītābhāṣyam
इदानीं सर्वकर्मफलत्यागं स्तौति —
श्रेयः हि प्रशस्यतरं ज्ञानम् । कस्मात् ? विवेकपूर्वकात् अभ्यासात् । तस्मादपि ज्ञानात् ज्ञानपूर्वकं ध्यानं विशिष्यते । ज्ञानवतो ध्यानात् अपि कर्मफलत्यागः, ‘विशिष्यते’ इति अनुषज्यते । एवं कर्मफलत्यागात् पूर्वविशेषणवतः शान्तिः उपशमः सहेतुकस्य संसारस्य अनन्तरमेव स्यात् , न तु कालान्तरम् अपेक्षते ॥
अज्ञस्य कर्मणि प्रवृत्तस्य पूर्वोपदिष्टोपायानुष्ठानाशक्तौ सर्वकर्मणां फलत्यागः श्रेयःसाधनम् उपदिष्टम् , न प्रथममेव । अतश्च ‘श्रेयो हि ज्ञानमभ्यासात्’ इत्युत्तरोत्तरविशिष्टत्वोपदेशेन सर्वकर्मफलत्यागः स्तूयते, सम्पन्नसाधनानुष्ठानाशक्तौ अनुष्ठेयत्वेन श्रुतत्वात् । केन साधर्म्येण स्तुतित्वम् ? ‘यदा सर्वे प्रमुच्यन्ते’(क. उ. २ । ३ । १४) इति सर्वकामप्रहाणात् अमृतत्वम् उक्तम् ; तत् प्रसिद्धम् । कामाश्च सर्वे श्रौतस्मार्तकर्मणां फलानि । तत्त्यागे च विदुषः ध्याननिष्ठस्य अनन्तरैव शान्तिः इति सर्वकामत्यागसामान्यम् अज्ञकर्मफलत्यागस्य अस्ति इति तत्सामान्यात् सर्वकर्मफलत्यागस्तुतिः इयं प्ररोचनार्था । यथा अगस्त्येन ब्राह्मणेन समुद्रः पीतः इति इदानीन्तनाः अपि ब्राह्मणाः ब्राह्मणत्वसामान्यात् स्तूयन्ते, एवं कर्मफलत्यागात् कर्मयोगस्य श्रेयःसाधनत्वमभिहितम् ॥ १२ ॥
In plain words
Now he praises the letting go of the fruit of every action —
Knowledge is better, truly more worthy of praise, than mere practice grounded in discrimination. And better still than that knowledge is meditation that grows out of knowledge. And better even than that knowledge-grounded meditation is letting go of the fruit of your actions altogether — the same word, 'is superior', simply carries over here too, even though the verse does not repeat it. So from this letting go, this final renunciation that already carries knowledge and meditation within it, peace, real cessation, of saṃsāra, roots and all, comes immediately. Not eventually. Not on some later occasion. Immediately.
Picture someone still caught up in doing — active, but not yet awake to who he really is. When he simply cannot manage the deeper practice already shown to him, the teaching offers him this instead: let go of the fruit of everything you do. That is taught as a way to the good — though never as the very first step for everyone. And here is why it earns such praise. The verse itself ranks things by degrees, 'better than mere practice is knowledge,' and inside that same ladder, giving up every fruit gets its own high place, because scripture says that even someone who already has better tools should practice this simpler renunciation when the better ones are out of reach. But on what grounds does it deserve such praise? Because the Upaniṣad already says it: when all desires are let go, immortality follows. That much is established fact. And what are desires, if not the fruits of every rite a person performs? So when someone wise, settled deep in meditation, gives all of that up, peace arrives at once, with no gap at all. That very letting-go of every desire is present, too, when someone still unawakened gives up the fruit of their actions. Because the two share that one thing, the praise stretches to cover this simpler case as well — not to claim they are equal, but to encourage. Think of Agastya, the sage who drank the whole ocean. Brahmins living now cannot do that, and yet they are still honored, simply for sharing his brahminhood. In the very same way, by giving up the fruit of action, the path of karma-yoga is declared to be a genuine means to the highest good.
Close to the Sanskrit
Now he praises the renunciation of the fruit of all actions —
Better, indeed more praiseworthy, is knowledge. Than what? Than practice preceded by discrimination. Than that knowledge too, meditation preceded by knowledge is superior. Than the meditation of one possessing knowledge too, the abandonment of the fruit of action [is superior] — '[is] superior' is carried over [from the earlier clause]. Thus, from the abandonment of the fruit of action, qualified by the preceding qualifiers, peace — the cessation — of saṃsāra together with its cause, would occur immediately following; it does not, however, require [waiting for] another time.
For one who is ignorant and engaged in action, when there is incapacity for practicing the means previously taught, renunciation of the fruit of all actions is taught as the means to the good — not as the very first step. And therefore, by the teaching of successive superiority in 'better indeed is knowledge than mere practice,' renunciation of the fruit of all action is praised, because, when there is incapacity for practicing even an already-acquired means, it is heard in scripture as something to be practiced. By what common property is this a case of praise? Because from 'when all desires are relinquished' (Kaṭha Up. 2.3.14), immortality is declared to follow from the relinquishing of all desire; that is well established. And desires, all of them, are the fruits of Śrauta and Smārta rites. And in the renunciation of that, for the wise one established in meditation, peace comes immediately; thus this general feature of renouncing all desire is present also in the ignorant one's renunciation of the fruit of action. And from that commonality, this praise of renouncing the fruit of all action exists in order to encourage. Just as, when it is said 'the ocean was drunk by Agastya the brahmin,' present-day brahmins too are praised on the ground of shared brahminhood, so, from renunciation of the fruit of action, the status of karma-yoga as a means to the good is declared.
▸Gītā Vāhini
“ఇందులో ఏదియునూ సులభముగా చేయుటకు సాధ్యము కాదందువా? చేయలేనందువా? తదుపరి గతి, స్థితి నీకే తెలియును” అని ఊరకుండెను. ఈ పవిత్ర బోధనను పట్టిచూడ, ‘భక్తుడు’ కాగోరు వారికి పని యందు మాత్రమే లక్ష్యముండవలెను కానీ, కాలమందు లక్ష్యముండకూడదని తెలియచున్నది. అందుకనే అభ్యాసము కంటే జ్ఞానము, జ్ఞానము కంటే ధ్యానము, ధ్యానము కంటే కర్మఫల త్యాగము చాలా శ్రేష్ఠమనియు గోపాలుడు తెలిపెను.
In plain words
“Do you say that not one of these is possible to do easily? Do you say you cannot do it? Then your course and your state are for you alone to know,” He said, and fell silent. When one looks closely at this sacred teaching, it becomes clear that those who wish to become a ‘devotee’ must keep their attention on the work alone, and not on the time. That is why Gopāla also declared that Jñāna is better than abhyāsa, dhyāna better than Jñāna, and the renunciation of the fruit of karma far better than dhyāna.